Thursday, October 30, 2008

The cost of [ThreadStatic] attribute

First of all, raw results:

Instance field: Operations: 2,650 B/s.
Static field: Operations: 2,630 B/s.
Volatile instance field: Operations: 2,649 B/s.
[ThreadStatic] field: Operations: 43,611 M/s.
Thread data slot: Operations: 4,068 M/s.

The test is actually quite simple: we read specified field in a loop. As before, on Core 2 Duo @2.66GHz. The code can be found in DataObjects.Net 4.0 test suite, see Xtensive.Core\Xtensive.Core.Tests\DotNetFramework\FieldTypeTest.cs.

- Reading regular, static or volatile field is quite cheap: ~ 0.2x in previously introduced metrics, or 20% of virtual method call time
- [ThreadStatic] fields are actually quite costly in comparison to others: ~ 14x.

Now the main question: why? It isn't so obvious [ThreadStatic] is ~ 60 times slower than static.

JITted [ThreadStatic] access code actually always consists of two parts:
- Call to a system routine returning address of [ThreadStatic] field by its token
- Regular field access instruction.

Obviously, the first part (call) "eats" almost the whole execution time: there is no more efficient way to get the address of such a field by its token rather than using hash table. As I've mentioned before, reading from a system hash table takes ~ 10x. So that's nearly what we have in this case.

Why they're implemented this way in .NET? I can't imagine why they didn't use some faster approach. E.g. I suspect calculating the lowest stack boundary (as well as the upper one) from the current stack pointer value is quite simple operation - something like bitwise and. Why we can't store the address of the first [ThreadStatic] location as fixed address nearby it, and use constant offset for each [ThreadStatic] field relatively to the address of the first one? In this case it would take ~ 1x to access it...

Ok, this is what could be, but in reality we have 14x.

Finally, there are thread data slots as well. But they're 10 times slower than [ThreadStatic] fields, so it's always better to simulate their behavior with e.g. a Dictionary stored in [ThreadStatic] field.


  1. Replies
    1. I have read your blog its very attractive and impressive. I like it your blog.

      Dot Net Training in Chennai Dot Net Training in Chennai .Net Online Training .Net Online Training Dot Net Training in Chennai

      Dot Net Online Training .Net Online Training ASP.NET Online Training ASP.NET Online Training